The Adventures Of Tintin

I had a chance to watch Steven Spielberg’s The Adventures OF Tintin a few nights ago, so just thought I’d discuss some thoughts on it.

Overall, it was a pretty good film, with some amazing action sequences, and some stunning cinematography. I have to admit, however, I reluctantly arrived at the conclusion, as I know some others have, that the hyper-real look of the film, mixed with the vaguely cartoony features/proportions of the characters, didn’t quite work for me. For me it seemed so close to reality, but with something just not quite right about it. A little more exaggeration in the proportions of aspects of the characters, such as the eyes, for instance, would have gone a long way to resolving this, but I also think the Motion Performance techniques used in the film may also have contributed significantly to this slightly disjointed look.

Cartoons aren’t supposed to move like, or closely resemble, real people – they’re cartoons! To quote Daniel D. Snyder at The Atlantic: “While all the characters sport some kind of cartoonish features—especially their ears and noses—their photorealistic eyes are somehow blank. It’s especially odd considering that it is the goal of animation to exaggerate features into even more outrageous modes of expression. Perfect mimicry in itself pointless. In bringing them to life, Spielberg has made the characters dead.”

I can’t help but wonder whether the fact that the film was directed by a live action director may have played a significant role in this. My guess is that had the film had been made by a director with background in animation, such as Brad Bird for example, we’d have seen something with a significantly more cohesive look. Equally so had Spielberg himself made this as a live action film.

However, having just finished reading a biography of Hergé (a couple of hours before I went to see the film in fact – I set myself a target!), I have to say, in most respects, this is actually probably pretty close to the movie that Hergé would have liked to have seen made. Spielberg really did do a pretty good job of embracing the spirit of Hergé the adventure story writer – just a shame he only partially embraced Hergé the cartoonist.

The Adventures Of Tintin Poster

Leave a Comment

Let us know your thoughts on this post but remember to place nicely folks!